Lizzie Brown
The New South Wales Supreme Court has delivered a significant decision for insolvency practitioners and distressed businesses, confirming that the Court may suspend an ATO notice where its continued operation threatens the objectives of voluntary administration.
In Hudson Global Resources (Aust) Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) v Commissioner of Taxation, Justice Brereton was required to consider the interaction between two powerful statutory regimes. On one side stood the Commissioner's broad tax collection powers under the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth). On the other stood the rescue-focused objectives of Part 5.3A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), which are designed to maximise the prospects of a financially distressed company surviving or, failing that, to deliver a better outcome for creditors than an immediate liquidation.
What is an ATO Garnishee Notice?
One of the ATO's most effective recovery mechanisms is the notice issued under section 260-5 of Schedule 1 to the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth). The provision allows the Commissioner to require a third party who owes money to a taxpayer, or who holds money on behalf of a taxpayer, to pay those funds directly to the ATO instead.
Importantly, the Commissioner does not need to obtain a court judgment before issuing the notice.
In practical terms, a notice allows the ATO to intercept money before it reaches the taxpayer. The recipient of the notice might be a bank, a customer, a debtor, a financier or any other entity that controls or owes money to the taxpayer. Once the notice is issued, the third party is legally required to divert funds to the Commissioner rather than the taxpayer.
For a business already experiencing financial difficulty, the consequences can be immediate. Cash that would otherwise be available to pay wages, suppliers, rent and other operating expenses is instead redirected towards the tax debt.
Why Part 5.3A Matters
To understand why the Court intervened, it is necessary to understand the purpose of voluntary administration.
Part 5.3A of the Corporations Act was introduced to provide financially distressed companies with an opportunity to restructure and survive rather than proceed immediately into liquidation. Section 435A identifies two key objectives. The first is to maximise the chances of the company, or as much as possible of its business, continuing in existence. The second, where survival is not achievable, is to provide a better return to creditors and members than would result from an immediate winding up.
Those objectives are not merely aspirational. They underpin the entire administration regime. Administrators are given breathing space to assess the company's affairs, preserve value, negotiate with creditors, seek additional funding and explore potential restructuring proposals. In many cases, maintaining trading operations is critical because a business that continues operating will often generate significantly greater value than one that ceases trading immediately.
The central question in Hudson was whether the continued operation of the ATO notice was undermining those statutory objectives.
The Facts
Hudson Global Resources operated a labour hire business. Prior to entering administration, the Commissioner issued a garnishee notice to Scottish Pacific Finance (ScotPac), which funded Hudson's operations through an invoice financing arrangement.
The notice required ScotPac to divert 20 per cent of all funding drawdowns directly to the ATO to reduce Hudson's substantial tax debt, which totalled approximately $19.64 million.
On 22 April 2026, Hudson entered voluntary administration.
At the time of the administrators' appointment, the company's financial position was precarious. Hudson owed more than $20 million to the ATO and approximately $8 million in unpaid wages and superannuation. The administrators were therefore confronted with a company experiencing acute cash flow difficulties while simultaneously carrying significant employee and tax liabilities.
The day after their appointment, the administrators wrote to the Commissioner requesting that the garnishee notice be withdrawn in light of the administration. The Commissioner declined to do so.
The refusal created an immediate problem. Every time Hudson drew down funding from ScotPac, a portion of those funds was automatically diverted to the ATO rather than being made available to support the company's ongoing operations.
As Justice Brereton noted at paragraph [8], the administrators ultimately had no realistic alternative but to negotiate revised funding arrangements with ScotPac. On 29 April 2026, they entered into a new funding agreement that amended the existing facility. The revised arrangement involved a reduced facility limit, an arrangement fee of $500,000 plus GST payable by instalments, an increase in management fees from $15,000 to $20,000, and an increase in the prevailing financing margin from 0.90 per cent to 1.50 per cent.
These revised terms reflected the heightened risks associated with continuing to fund a company in administration. They also further strained Hudson's already fragile financial position.
The Administrators Seek Urgent Relief
They sought orders restraining the Commissioner from continuing to collect funds under the notice, declarations that ScotPac was not required to comply with the notice, orders suspending the operation of the notice pursuant to section 447A of the Corporations Act, and orders requiring the Commissioner to repay monies received after the administrators' appointment.
The Court's Decision
Justice Brereton accepted that the continued operation of the notice was fundamentally inconsistent with the objectives of Part 5.3A.
A particularly significant aspect of the judgment was the Court's recognition of the practical effect of the notice on the administration process. At paragraph [53], Justice Brereton observed:
"The effect of the ATO Notice is to syphon to the benefit of the Commissioner (who is otherwise an unsecured creditor with no particular priority under s 556), property that would otherwise be available to the administrators in their efforts to maximise the chances of Hudson continuing in existence or providing a better return to creditors and members than would result from an immediate winding up."
This passage goes to the heart of the Court's reasoning. Although the Commissioner possessed statutory recovery powers, the practical effect of the notice was to divert funds away from the administration process and towards one unsecured creditor.
Justice Brereton also emphasised the importance of the statutory purpose underpinning voluntary administration. His Honour noted:
"The purpose of Part 5.3A is to provide for the business, property and affairs of an insolvent company to be administered in a way that maximises the chances of the company, or as much as possible of its business, continuing in existence, or if that is not possible, results in a better return for the company's creditors and members than would result from an immediate winding up."
Why This Decision Matters
The significance of the decision extends beyond Hudson itself.
ATO notices are among the Commissioner's most powerful debt recovery tools because they allow funds to be intercepted before they reach the taxpayer. In many circumstances, the notices are highly effective and difficult to challenge.
However, Hudson demonstrates that there are limits.
Where the continued operation of a garnishee notice deprives administrators of essential working capital, compromises trading operations, threatens employee wages, jeopardises a restructuring proposal or undermines a potential going concern sale, the Court may be willing to intervene.
For companies attempting to navigate financial distress, and for the practitioners tasked with rescuing them, that clarification is likely to prove enormously significant.