Whether Dual Examinations Are an Abuse of Process — In the matter of FSM Development [2025] NSWSC 988

Sanae Prasad

What is an Examination Order?

An examination order is a NSW court order requiring a person or company representative to attend court to give information about how they will be able to pay a judgment debt. This is authorised under ss 596A and 596B or the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

The examination process is designed to give judgment creditors the information they need to work out the most effective way to enforce a debt.

This is a two-step process:

  1. Examination Notice The judgment creditor sends the debtor an examination notice. This is a questionnaire-style document requesting information on assets, liabilities, income and similar matters.

  2. Examination Order If the judgment debtor does not respond within 28 days, the creditor can apply to the court for an examination order. Once served with the order, the judgment debtor must attend court to answer questions and produce documents concerning their ability to pay the debt.

In the matter of FSM Development [2025] NSWSC 988

Background Facts

  • A third-party lender loaned money to FSM, secured over a property at Ashfield. FSM and its guarantors were owned by Mr Guo.

  • A related company of Mr Guo separately borrowed from Zagga Investments for a Lindfield property, secured by a second mortgage over the same Ashfield property. The original lender and Zagga entered into a deed of priority.

  • In August 2024, an RWC-managed trust acquired the original loan and substantially amended its terms, raising the interest rate from 7.79% to 32.4% and imposing a $1.22 million establishment fee. Within days, over half of the loan was on-sold to a Keyview-linked trust.

  • These amendments were subsequently challenged by FSM, its Liquidators, and Stingray.

The Issue

The Liquidators commenced proceedings in the Federal Court of Australia (FCA), seeking examinations of RWC employees under s 596B of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

Separately, Stingray Management Pty Ltd (a creditor) sought its own examinations of the RWC employees and RWC in the NSW Supreme Court, covering largely the same transactions and individuals.

The key issue was whether the examination orders sought by Stingray should be set aside or stayed on the basis that they duplicated the FCA examinations.

Legal Principles

Under s 121(3) of the Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW) or UCPR r 49.19, the Court has power to set aside or vary a Registrar's order, including an order for examination. Even where an examination summons is issued for a proper purpose, it may still be set aside if it is unjustifiably oppressive (Re LED (South Coast) Pty Ltd (2009) 76 NSWLR 428 at 430).

The Court also has an inherent power to prevent abuse of process, which allows it to refuse or stay an examination order. Abuse of process generally falls into one or more of the following categories:

  1. Use of the court's processes for an illegitimate purpose;

  2. Use of the court's processes in a manner that is unjustifiably oppressive; or

  3. Use of the court's processes in a way that would bring the administration of justice into disrepute.

(Walton v ACN 004 410 833 Ltd (formerly Arrium Ltd) (in liq) (2022) 275 CLR 508)

Judgment

(a) Illegitimate Purpose and Abuse of Process

The Court found that although Stingray's proposed examinations overlapped factually with the Liquidators', they pursued Stingray's own distinct claims. On that basis, the examinations were for a proper purpose, and no abuse of process was established on this ground.

(b) Oppression

The Court rejected the broader submission that conducting separate examinations is inherently abusive or oppressive. However, because Stingray had funded the FCA examinations and had access to the resulting transcripts, it was closely connected to that process. In these circumstances, it was unjustifiably oppressive for Stingray not to take active steps to avoid unnecessary duplication, given the risk of repeated questioning and additional costs for the examinees.

Remedy

Rather than setting aside the examination summonses outright, the Court stayed them. Stingray was directed to review the FCA transcripts and identify genuinely new topics of examination before the stay would be lifted and its examinations could proceed.

What We Can Learn

Pursuing examinations which overlap with another party's ongoing or completed examinations is not, of itself, an abuse of process. However, there must be a genuinely pursuing a distinct claim. Parties contemplating parallel or follow-on examinations should take active steps to avoid duplication by reviewing documents and transcripts, to prevent unnecessary waste of time and costs.

Next
Next

A Significant Win for Business Rescue Efforts